Reading "Teaching Grammar in the Context of Writing" by Constance Weaver showed that teaching grammar when it is relevant to writing serves a more practical use than then reading a text book and working on sentences in the book that need their grammar corrected. I want to implement this kind of teaching in my future classroom because it will be relevant to my students and it is the best way they will learn the most grammar the can. I do think that I may have to deal with a lot of parents who disagree with this methods, but I think we need to educate them to the reality of how well it really works.
There is an article in The Atlantic that talks more about the idea that teaching students grammar in "drill and kill" methods can actually hinder their ability to learn grammar. So I think all teachers and district should move away from these methods but it is hard to determine if they really will. There are many books written to help teachers implement the new ways of teaching grammar that will help guide them through it. Hopefully educators will begin to see the benefits of teaching grammar through writing and it will take the place of these "drill and kill" methods.
Marissa, while you've made the argument that "drill and kill" does not effectively teach grammar, we also need to take the next step...what DOES help students improve the grammar of their writing? (Next post!)
ReplyDelete